Why Chain of Custody Plays an Important Role in Criminal Cases

CHAIN OF CUSTODY - IMPORTANT ROLE

Chain of custody is not a casual term that everybody is familiar with but it is one that holds paramount importance in criminal cases. It is a track record of everything found at an alleged crime scene that is used to prove or crack a case. In simple words, any criminal case depends on the evidence presented in court. The chain of custody shows to the court that the evidence presented at trial is the same as presented in court. If there’s any discrepancy in the handling of evidence, then it can be challenged.

What is a Chain of Custody?

Before one can discuss the importance, it is essential to understand the definition of the chain of custody. Chain of custody definition would be, chronological documentation that maintains the record of the handling of evidence in a criminal case. Confused? Think of a crime scene. All the evidence found at the crime scene is collected by the police officers. Then the evidence is transferred for examination and analysis by forensic experts. Based on their reporting, the evidence is used in a trial.

All the collection, examination, analysis, and storage need the movement of the evidence. All these details are filled in the chain of custody form. It is crucial to maintain proper documentation of all this activity to ensure that at no point evidence was compromised. This chain of custody provides a correct record of the handling of evidence throughout the investigation. Evidence can include anything from blood, DNA samples, clothing, digital data, and such. This is why it is essential to maintain a proper record of the chain of custody to ensure that at no time was the evidence handled improperly.

The chain of custody form mentions everyone that at any point came in contact with the evidence along with the details on what was the evidence used for. The documentation is also required to include complete details on how, where, and by whom the evidence was moved. In the manner used for transfer and storage, all the little details play an important role in the chain of custody.

Importance of Chain of Custody in Criminal Cases

Needless to say, the evidence is what decides the fate of the trial. In any criminal case, evidence is pivotal. Delicate evidence like blood samples and DNA samples can greatly affect the fate of the case. Any mishandling during transfer or examination can lead to tampering with the evidence. If at any point, a discrepancy is found, it can be challenged in court and ruled inadmissible.

Learn More: General principles of crime scene investigation

The responsibility of maintaining a clean chain of custody falls on the prosecutor. So if a defendant feels that there has been any mistake in handling the evidence, they can challenge it and prove that the evidence is not in the same condition or replaced or tampered with and cannot be used for a conviction. It holds such weight that no testimony can be considered relevant if the defendant can prove that the chain of custody has been broken.

To end with, the chain of custody is given more importance than the evidence itself since it is what proves the authenticity of the evidence.

Best Practices in Evidence Handling

In the chain of custody, maintaining the integrity of evidence is paramount. Implementing best practices in evidence handling ensures that the entire process, from the crime scene to the courtroom, is seamless. This includes secure packaging methods, temperature controls for sensitive materials, and strict protocols for transfer. Emphasizing these practices adds an extra layer of credibility to the chain of custody, assuring the court that the evidence is handled with the utmost care.

Digital Evidence in the Chain of Custody

In the digital age, criminal investigations often involve digital evidence such as emails, images, and computer files. Understanding how to properly document the chain of custody for digital evidence is crucial. This includes recording the exact process of acquisition, the tools used for analysis, and ensuring the preservation of metadata. Integrating these steps into the chain of custody not only modernises the process but also reinforces its reliability in the face of evolving technology.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Chain of Custody

Q: Is the chain of custody only relevant for physical evidence?

A: No, the chain of custody extends to all types of evidence, including digital data, ensuring a comprehensive record of its handling.

Q: Can the defence challenge the chain of custody at any point during the trial?

A: Yes, the defence has the right to challenge the chain of custody at any stage if they suspect mishandling or tampering with the evidence.

Q: How long should the chain of custody documentation be retained?

A: Retaining the chain of custody records for an extended period is advisable to address post-conviction challenges even after the trial.

Q: Is the chain of custody applicable only to criminal cases?

A: While prominently used in criminal cases, the chain of custody is also crucial in civil cases, particularly those involving disputed evidence or property.

Q: What happens if there is a break in the chain of custody?

A: A break in the chain of custody may lead to the evidence being deemed unreliable or inadmissible. The party challenging the chain of custody must demonstrate how the break may have compromised the evidence.

Q: Who has access to the chain of custody documentation?

A: Typically, the prosecution and defence teams, as well as the court, have access to the chain of custody documentation. It is considered a crucial part of the discovery process.

Q: Can a witness testify about the chain of custody without presenting the actual documentation?

A: While a witness may provide testimony about the chain of custody, presenting the actual documentation adds a layer of credibility and is often preferred in legal proceedings.

Q: What role does the chain of custody play in plea negotiations?

A: The chain of custody can influence plea negotiations by affecting the strength of the evidence. A solid chain of custody may strengthen the prosecution’s case, while challenges to the chain may impact the negotiation dynamics.

Q: Can the defence request an independent examination of the evidence during the trial?

A: Yes, the defence may request an independent examination of the evidence to ensure its integrity. The results of such examinations can be introduced as evidence during the trial.

 

The Carlson Company offers a wide variety of forensic lab testing services and Drugs Test Panels. FREE real-person client care by email or phone Monday – Thursday, 9 AM – 4 PM Mountain time zone. If we miss your call leave a voice mail or send an email. We check our contact form emails and voice messages regularly and promise to get back to you ASAP.